What level of democracy does China have?

'DEMOCRACY IS IMPORTANT' vs. 'MY COUNTRY IS DEMOCRATIC'

People often ask what level of democracy does China have, and it takes time to explain that democracy comes in very different shapes and sizes

Asking what level of democracy does China have is like asking what level of democracy Switzerland has?

China and Switzerland have some of the highest levels of democracy of any country on earth, and Chinese people care greatly about democracy.

'DEMOCRACY IS IMPORTANT' vs. 'MY COUNTRY IS DEMOCRATIC'

How Democratic is China?

America and China are both republics, and both claim to be democratic. But finally, how democratic is China?

A glance at history is always a good start. Here’s Mencius, Confucius’ greatest disciple, on the relationship of the state to the people: The state is secondary, and the Ruler is the least important: only those who please the people can rule.

2500 years later, Mao Zedong replied to a Reuters correspondent who asked him what kind of government he was planning for China: It will implement Dr. Sun Yat-sen’s three principles of democracy, Lincoln’s principle of ‘of the people, by the people, for the people,’ and Roosevelt’s Atlantic Charter. It will assure the independence and unity of the nation and cooperate with all democratic powers etc.

Roman Democracy

Our political tradition is Roman, and one of our system’s weaknesses is that citizens lose control of politicians once we elect them. It’s one reason why, like our Roman forebears, we regard government as our biggest problem: they don’t keep their promises. Actually, the Romans copied their ideas from Ancient Greeks, especially from Athens’ famous legislator, Pericles.

Current Chinese Democracy

Imagine that, instead of electing eloquent amateurs, we hired professional sociologists, statisticians, political scientists, economists and told them to conduct public surveys to identify our problems.

Then we told them to help state and local governments who wanted to experiment with solutions. They should track local satisfaction for a few years, discard failed policies, and promote successful ones.

California might adopt Canadian-style

Medicare and–if the Golden State’s medical bills fell fifty percent and Californians lived three years longer, we would send volunteers to audit California’s results then, if everything checked out, pass national legislation that would cut everyone’s health costs and allow us all to live longer. That’s what China does: they spend half as much as we spend and live longer, healthier lives likewise.
What level of democracy does China have?

 

 

China's Responsive Government

Beijing has promised to extend the democratic rule of law as education levels rise, but there has been another informal democracy at work for three thousand years.

Any citizen can petition the government.

Any citizen also can petition the government with demand or complaint etc. Historically at any time but especially now, when Congress is meeting with the Peoples Consultative Congress. Thousands of insistent constituents appear on their doorsteps with written petitions. The protocol requires them to start at the neighborhood level then, if they are still dissatisfied, finally go to the next level, all the way to the NPC if needed. In fact, there is a special office, the State Bureau for Letters and Calls, where everyone, even non-citizens, can lodge petitions.

Participatory Democracy

Legislation, which was once published in newspapers and posted on neighborhood bulletin boards, now blossoms online. Every draft is posted for citizens, non-citizens, national and international businesses alike to comment and critique–and they do. If there is strong pushback or resistance to proposed laws, they’re sent back for amendment. And if that is too cumbersome, there is the constitutional right to demonstrate publicly.

Smartphones, social media, and streaming video to multiply the effects of public demonstrations (as 150,000 ‘mass incidents’ in 2018 testify). Rowdy protests–usually triggered by local officials’ unfairness, dishonesty, or incompetence–are cheap, exciting, and safe since the police are unarmed. Indignant[14] citizens paint signs, alert NGOs and the media, recruit neighbors, bang drums, shout slogans, and Livestream their parade, etc.

Responses

That once took months now takes hours. Targeted officials–usually after a phone call from an angry superior–speed to the scene. Bow deeply, apologize profusely, kiss babies, explain that they had no idea that such things were going on, and promise brighter tomorrows. Since cell phones became, ubiquitous local officials’ approval has risen from forty-five to fifty-five percent. And by 2025, should rival Americans’ seventy percent.

From land redistribution in the 1950s to communes in the 60s to the Great Leap Forward, as well as the Cultural Revolution, Reform, and Opening and anti-corruption, Chinese politics are almost unrecognizable from one decade to the next, yet policy support rivals Switzerland’s. Tsinghua Professor Daniel Bell[15] credits democracy at the bottom, experiments in the middle, and meritocracy at the top for a string of policy successes. And The New York Times’s Tom Friedman says wistfully, “If we could just be China for one day we could actually authorize the right decisions.”

President Hu Jintao

Former President Hu Jintao, who formalized Trial Spots, wisely observed that there’s more to China’s democratic process than meets the eye, “Taking from each according his ability and giving to each according to his need requires democratic rule of law, fairness and justice, honesty and fraternity, abundant energy, stability, orderliness, harmony between people and the environment and sustainable development.”

Words to ponder.

China’s Congress in Action

Hong Kong: Democracy Trial Spot

 

—————————————————————————————

Interests

[1] Confucius’ most famous disciple, Mencius, lived 372 BC – 289 BC.

[2] Moreover, Record High Name Government as Most Important Problem. Gallup. February 18, 2019

[3] The “Surprise” of Authoritarian Resilience in China. Wenfang Tang

[4] The Voting Rights Act of 1965

[5] William Sewell and I Stayed in China.

[6] The China Democratic League is for teachers from elementary school to universities. Since Confucius is China’s archetypal teacher and teachers are held in high regard by society as a whole, this is a highly influential party.

[7] The Kuomintang of China, KMT; obviously (sometimes Guomindang) often translated as the Nationalist Party of China) is a major political party in the Republic of China on Taiwan, based in Taipei, and is currently the opposition political party in Taiwan’s Legislative Yuan.

[8] The Jiusan Society is for Ph.D. scientists, mostly physicists, and engineers, whose position is ‘everything should be run by science’. Very big on pushing for climate initiatives, environmental protection, more R&D budget, better health policies, etc.

[9] Wikipedia

[10] Authoritarian Gridlock? Understanding Delay in the Chinese Legislative System. Rory Truex. Journal of Comparative Political Studies, April 2018

[11] The lowest recorded legislative support is sixty-four percent for the Three Gorges Dam project. Which finally repays its original investment every two years. It was the biggest and most expensive single-site project in history whose lake has changed the earth’s rotation, so legislators’ caution in their generation is understandable.

[12] Public perception of genetically-modified (GM) food: A Nationwide Chinese Consumer Study. Kai Cui & Sharon P. Shoemaker. npj Science of Food volume 2, Article number: 10 (2018)

[13] Jeff J. Brown, China Rising, etc.

[14] Tang, Populist Authoritarianism.

[15] The China Model: Political Meritocracy and the Limits of Democracy.(p. 9) Daniel Bell etc.

 

Have any Question?

10 thoughts on “What level of democracy does China have?”

  1. Hi, I am tom Feeley , editor of an online source of news and information. ( http://www.informationclearinghouse.info) Having read some of your content wanted to ask If I may republish article as the appear on your website.We also send links almost daily to over 100,000 around the who have chosen to subscribe over the last 20 years.

    We are not a commercial website, in that we do not sell or advertise to our readers and are supported 100% by donations.

    The purpose of the website is to provide information not normally available to U.S. and international readers to better enable them to make choices based on factual information rather than propaganda.

    Perhaps you could peruse the website and let me know if republishing the articles meets your criteria.

    Peace and Joy

    Tom Feeley

  2. Very interesting, actually an introduction for most in the US. I would suggest that the graphics underemphasize the chart coordinates and distort through perspective: clear graphics are more persuasive than simple-looking graphics.

    Incidentally, I found your site through the above site http://www.informationclearinghouse.info

  3. Pingback: Links 2/27/2021 | naked capitalism

  4. Pingback: Links 2/27/2021 - Breaking News log

  5. Pingback: Links 2/27/2021 – Viral News Connection

  6. Pingback: Links 2/27/2021 – Church Security

  7. Pingback: How Democratic is China? – Counter Information

  8. Calling the Kuomintang a major party when they’re in Taiwan feels… misleading.

    Also, interesting that Chinese citizens find *any* officials less responsive than Americans, just about the least democratic country with supposedly free elections. If the last year has proven anything it’s the hollowing out of the American government, and at least the possibility of responsiveness in China. The whole baby formula thing was a huge blow to the Chinese system, it’s been good to see it able to handle other crises.

  9. Pingback: Is China's Constitution Democratic? - Here Comes China!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share:

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on linkedin
hcc headline2 mobile 1

GET ALL THE WEEK'S NEWS
WITH YOUR SUBSCRIPTION TO THE TOP CHINA NEWSLETTER

Amazon BUY THIS BOOK:

Most Popular

Categories